Comparison of Emergency Evacuation Standards for Disabled Persons: IBC (USA) vs. BSL (Japan)

Category	IBC (USA)	BSL (Japan)
Scope & Application	Applies to all public buildings, assembly occupancies, high-rises, and facilities with mobility-impaired occupants.	Applies to public buildings under Japan’s Barrier-Free Law and disaster management regulations.
Accessible Means of Egress	Requires at least two accessible egress routes per IBC 1009.2.	Requires at least one accessible evacuation route in public-use buildings.
Areas of Refuge (Refuge Spaces)	Required in multi-story buildings unless an accessible exit is provided (IBC 1009.6).	Similar refuge areas required for large buildings, often linked to fireproof areas.
Stairway Evacuation for Wheelchair Users	Evacuation chairs or assistance required where elevators cannot be used (IBC 1009.8).	Evacuation sleds or lifts often required, with trained staff assistance in public buildings.
Use of Elevators During Emergency	Permitted only for fire service-accessible elevators or specifically designed occupant evacuation elevators (IBC 3008).	Similar, but Japan emphasizes earthquake-resistant elevators for emergency evacuation.
Fire-Resistant Egress Routes	Minimum 1-hour fire-rated enclosures for accessible stairwells (IBC Table 1023.2).	Requires fireproof stairwells with a minimum 2-hour fire resistance in high-rise buildings.
Emergency Communication & Signage	Two-way emergency communication required in Areas of Refuge (IBC 1009.8.1).	Emergency call buttons and voice guidance required in accessible refuge areas.
Training & Drills	Fire evacuation plans must incorporate disabled persons (IBC 403.4.7).	Japan’s Disaster Countermeasure Act mandates evacuation assistance plans for disabled individuals.
Alternative Evacuation Devices	Evacuation chairs, lifts, or sleds are recommended but not always required.	Mandatory evacuation devices for multi-story buildings with high occupancy.
Seismic Considerations	Not a primary focus, but buildings must comply with seismic safety codes.	Stronger emphasis on earthquake evacuation, including automatic safety stop elevators.

Key Differences:

• IBC requires Areas of Refuge in multi-story buildings where an accessible egress route is unavailable, while BSL often integrates these with fireproof spaces.
• Japan mandates earthquake-resistant evacuation measures, while IBC focuses on fire safety and stair-assisted evacuation.
• Evacuation devices (sleds, chairs, lifts) are more commonly mandatory in Japan than in the U.S.
• Training for disabled evacuation is explicitly part of Japan’s disaster preparedness laws, whereas IBC requires integration into fire safety plans.

Recommendations for Emergency Evacuation for Disabled Persons

For IBC (USA):

1. Increase the Number of Accessible Egress Routes – Require at least two fully accessible exits in all multi-story buildings.
2. Expand Areas of Refuge – Enforce larger, well-equipped refuge spaces with proper ventilation, communication, and fireproofing.
3. Integrate Seismic-Resistant Evacuation Elevators – Encourage fire and earthquake-resistant elevators with emergency backup power.
4. Mandate Evacuation Chairs in High-Rise Buildings – Require at least one evacuation chair per stairwell for safe assisted evacuation.
5. Improve Emergency Communication – Standardize haptic feedback, visual signals, and multilingual guidance in emergency systems.
6. Strengthen Fire-Rated Stairwells – Upgrade fireproof stairwells to meet seismic-resistant standards for increased safety.
7. Require Inclusive Evacuation Drills – Enforce annual emergency drills that include assistance for disabled persons.
8. Introduce Smart Evacuation Technology – Develop real-time tracking systems to alert emergency responders to disabled occupants’ locations.
9. Enhance Outdoor Assembly Accessibility – Ensure accessible gathering points with clear signage, seating, and emergency call stations.

• These updates will improve compliance with accessibility and life safety standards in high-rise buildings, stadiums, and public venues.

---

For BSL (Japan):

1. Increase the Number of Accessible Egress Routes – Require at least two emergency exits for disabled persons in multi-story public buildings.
2. Standardize Fireproof Refuge Areas – Establish well-defined refuge spaces with fireproofing, communication systems, and emergency lighting.
3. Enhance Seismic-Resistant Elevators – Require earthquake-resistant evacuation elevators in all high-rise and public buildings.
4. Mandate Evacuation Sleds in All Multi-Story Buildings – Ensure every stairwell has a designated evacuation sled for safe assisted evacuation.
5. Strengthen Emergency Communication Systems – Improve audible guidance, braille/tactile signage, and emergency call buttons.
6. Reinforce Fireproof & Earthquake-Resistant Stairwells – Implement mandatory seismic upgrades for all emergency stair enclosures.
7. Expand Nationwide Disaster Preparedness Training – Mandate annual inclusive emergency drills focused on assisting disabled evacuees.
8. Adopt Smart Evacuation Technology – Utilize tracking apps and emergency locator systems for rapid assistance during disasters.
9. Improve Outdoor Evacuation Areas – Designate accessible outdoor assembly zones with seating, shade, and emergency communication tools.

• By implementing these changes, Japan’s Barrier-Free Law and Disaster Countermeasure Act can provide safer, more inclusive evacuation options in both fire and earthquake emergencies