General Definition
- Fire-retardant interior finishes refer to materials used for walls, ceilings, and other interior surfaces that are treated to limit flame spread and smoke development in case of fire.
- In Group A-1 occupancies (e.g., theaters, auditoriums, concert halls), these materials reduce fire propagation, improve visibility during evacuation, and minimize toxic smoke exposure.
Comparison Table
Element | IBC Table 803.11 (USA) – Fire-Retardant Interior Finishes | BSL Article 35 (Japan) – Interior Finish Fire Protection |
Surface Flame Spread Index (Walls & Ceilings) | – ≤25 flame spread index (Class A). | – Stricter—≤20 flame spread index (more fire-resistant). |
Smoke Developed Index | – ≤450 smoke developed index. | – Stricter—≤300 smoke developed index to reduce visibility obstruction. |
Fire-Retardant Coating Requirements | – Coatings allowed for flame spread reduction. | – Stricter—coatings must be factory-applied and tested. |
Interior Finish Classifications | – Class A, B, or C based on flame spread and smoke index. | – More stringent classification system ensuring lower flame spread and smoke release. |
Testing & Certification Standards | – Materials must be tested per ASTM E84 or UL 723. | – Materials must be tested per ISO 5660 or Japan Fire Testing Center (JFTC) standards. |
Key Differences
- Surface Flame Spread Index (Walls & Ceilings):
- IBC allows materials with a flame spread index of ≤25 (Class A).
- BSL enforces stricter limits, allowing only materials with a flame spread index of ≤20.
- Smoke Developed Index:
- IBC sets a maximum smoke developed index of 450.
- BSL enforces a stricter limit of 300 to minimize smoke buildup during evacuation.
- Fire-Retardant Coating Requirements:
- IBC allows field-applied coatings to improve fire resistance.
- BSL mandates that fire-retardant coatings must be factory-applied and pre-tested. (Stricter requirement.)
- Interior Finish Classifications:
- IBC classifies materials as Class A, B, or C based on fire spread and smoke development.
- BSL applies more stringent material classifications to ensure lower flame spread and smoke release.
- Testing & Certification Standards:
- IBC relies on ASTM E84 or UL 723 test methods.
- BSL requires compliance with ISO 5660 or Japan Fire Testing Center (JFTC) standards.
Recommendations for Improvement
Issue | IBC Recommendation | BSL Recommendation |
Lower Surface Flame Spread Index | Reduce maximum allowable flame spread index from 25 to 20, aligning with BSL. | Maintain stricter flame spread index but allow for alternative compliance paths. |
Stronger Smoke Development Limits | Reduce smoke developed index from 450 to 300 to enhance occupant safety. | Maintain strict smoke development limits but clarify exceptions for specialty materials. |
Stricter Fire-Retardant Coating Requirements | Require fire-retardant coatings to be factory-applied and tested. | Improve testing regulations for field-applied coatings in existing buildings. |
Key Insights
- Surface Flame Spread Index (Walls & Ceilings):
- IBC allows up to 25 (Class A).
- BSL enforces a stricter limit of 20.
- Smoke Developed Index:
- IBC allows up to 450.
- BSL enforces a stricter limit of 300. (Better smoke control.)
- Fire-Retardant Coating Requirements:
- IBC allows field-applied coatings.
- BSL enforces stricter factory-applied coating requirements.
- Interior Finish Classifications:
- IBC uses Class A, B, and C designations.
- BSL enforces more stringent classifications to reduce fire spread.
- Testing & Certification Standards:
- IBC relies on ASTM E84 and UL 723.
- BSL enforces ISO 5660 and Japan Fire Testing Center (JFTC) standards.
Summary
- BSL enforces stricter fire-retardant interior finish requirements than IBC for A-1 occupancies.
- BSL allows only materials with a lower flame spread index (≤20), while IBC permits up to 25.
- BSL enforces a lower smoke developed index (≤300) to minimize smoke hazards, while IBC allows up to 450.
- BSL mandates fire-retardant coatings to be factory-applied, whereas IBC allows field application.
- Both IBC and BSL require rigorous testing, but BSL enforces stricter compliance with ISO 5660 and JFTC standards.